Former Negeri Sembilan EXCO Members Withdraw Lawsuit Over State Constitutional Crisis
SEREMBAN: The High Court here was informed today that 10 former Negeri Sembilan State Executive Council (EXCO) members have withdrawn their originating summons against the State Secretary and two other parties over the constitutional crisis in the state, without liberty to file the suit again.
High Court Judge Roz Mawar Rozain allowed the withdrawal after the plaintiffs’ lawyer, Datuk Mohd Hafarizam Harun, informed the court that his clients had decided to withdraw the entire suit, including the application under the Federal Court’s original jurisdiction.
Hafarizam said the decision was made following recent developments concerning the resignation of Menteri Besar Datuk Ismail Lasim, taking into account constitutional provisions stipulating that all state EXCO members also cease to hold office when the Menteri Besar resigns.
“The reason for withdrawing this suit is that recent developments have overtaken the disputed issues, and in accordance with constitutional provisions, when the Menteri Besar resigns, the entire EXCO also ceases to hold office or is dissolved,” he said during proceedings here today.
However, Roz Mawar clarified that Ismail had not officially resigned at the time of the proceedings, as he had only submitted his resignation letter and the consent of the Yang di-Pertuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan, Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir, had yet to be obtained.
Hafarizam said all the plaintiffs had initially sought an adjournment of the proceedings until this Friday to allow Tuanku Muhriz time to issue a royal decree concerning the resignation. However, after discussions with his clients, they decided to withdraw the proceedings.
The court also ordered the plaintiffs to pay costs of RM20,000 to the first defendant, the Negeri Sembilan State Secretary; RM20,000 to the second defendant, the Negeri Sembilan State Government; and RM8,000 to the third defendant, the Negeri Sembilan Dewan Keadilan dan Undang (DKU), subject to allocatur.
In her judgment, Roz Mawar said the court would not prevent any litigating party from withdrawing legal proceedings, noting that such action might be the more appropriate course.
However, she said the court had devoted considerable time and resources to handling the case since the originating summons was filed five months ago with a certificate of urgency, including managing various applications and setting timelines for the hearing of preliminary objections.
She said parties invoking the court’s jurisdiction, particularly in urgent matters involving constitutional questions relating to the state government, also bore responsibility for the use of judicial resources entrusted to serve the public interest.
Earlier, Hafarizam also informed the court that the suit was being withdrawn without liberty to file it again, including through judicial review.
Counsel for the first defendant, Datuk Dr Cyrus Das, and counsel for the second defendant, Razlan Hadri Zulkifli, confirmed their agreement to the withdrawal based on the agreed terms, while counsel for the third defendant, Steven Thiru, expressed the same position.
The 10 former EXCO members had filed the originating summons seeking an interpretation of the State Constitution, naming the Negeri Sembilan State Secretary and the state government as defendants, while DKU was granted permission to intervene and was included as the third defendant in the suit.
The plaintiffs were also represented by lawyers Tan Sri Azhar Azizan Harun, Datuk Syed Faisal Al-Edros Syed Abdullah, Norhazira Abu Haiyan and Muhammad Luqman Hakeem Abas, while the first defendant was also represented by lawyers Abdul Rashid Ismail, Siti Nurani Md Zahidi and Diong Pei Jing.
Lawyers Razlan Hadri Zulkifli, Marisa Regina Mohd Aris Rizal and Muhammad Yazid Mohamad Salim represented the state government, while DKU was represented by lawyers Steven Thiru, David Mathew, Shafrin Halim and Gurjeevan Singh.
BERNAMA